Boca Grande Restaurants (2025 Update)

If you’re anything like me, food isn’t just a necessity—it’s a big part of the traveling adventure. Boca Grande, nestled on Gasparilla Island, is home to a wide variety of dining gems that cater to every craving. You’ll find everything from charming cafés to fine dining options here. Whether it’s your first visit or you’re practically a local, discovering the best Boca Grande restaurants is an essential part of soaking up this island’s laid-back vibe. Stick around, and I’ll guide you through every spot worth checking out—I promise, you won’t leave hungry.

For even more details about exploring the area, check out my post about The Perfect Two-Day Itinerary for Exploring Gasparilla Island.

Restaurants, Cafes & Convenience Stores (A-Z)

When hunger calls in Boca Grande, there are quite a few options, and I guarantee that you can’t go wrong no matter which one you choose. Whether you want fresh seafood, comfort food, or something to grab-and-go, these spots have something for everyone.

Here is a full list of all Boca Grande restaurants, cafes, ice cream shops, and convenience stores (basically, anywhere that you can buy food on the island) listed alphabetically for easy navigation.

Bella Vida Boca Grande

Category: Breakfast, lunch, coffee, smoothies

Modern, fresh, and exciting—Bella Vida Boca Grande brings something unique to the island. Their menu features dishes like breakfast sandwiches and acai bowls. Whether you’re in for brunch or a mid-afternoon snack, it’s easy to see why this spot has become a local favorite.

Visit their website for the menu and hours of operation.

Eagle Grille & Miller’s Dockside

Category: Lunch, dinner

Located right next to Boca Grande Marina (formerly Miller’s Marina), both Eagle Grille and Miller’s Dockside are perfect for anyone arriving by boat (but also accessible via car or golf cart). Miller’s is the go-to for a casual, sports bar feel, while Eagle Grille upstairs is more of a fine dining experience with great waterfront views.

Visit their website for menus and hours of operation.

Hudson’s Grocery

Category: Grocery, grab-and-go, convenience store

Sometimes you just want convenience without compromising quality. Hudson’s Grocery isn’t just a grocery store—it’s a grab-and-go dream, offering premade sandwiches, salads, and even fresh-baked goodies. The perfect solution for when you’re heading out on the boat or back to the beach. Plus, their grocery options ensure your vacation rental fridge is well-stocked with all the essentials. Their premade options change daily, so you never know what you’re going to find!

Visit their Facebook page for the latest updates.

The Inn Bakery

Category: Breakfast, lunch, coffee, pastries

It’s back! In 2022, their building was destroyed by Hurricane Ian, but after a long two years, The Gasparilla Inn Bakery is back and thriving in a new location. With the same great pastries, croissants, and coffee that’s as smooth as an island breeze, you’ll start your day on the right note. It’s a cozy little spot where you can watch Boca Grande come to life every morning. Their lunch options are just as good (Seriously. Ask me how many times I’ve had their Ham & Brie sandwich).

Visit the Inn’s website for more information.

Kappy’s Market

Category: Grab-and-go, convenience store

On the north end of the island, Kappy’s is a low-key gem if you’re craving fresh produce and ready-to-eat options without sitting down for a full meal. Their deli is packed with delicious to-go items like wraps and pasta salads, making a quick lunch or picnic a breeze. Swing by for everything you need for a cooler packed full of local flavors, as well as great souvineers, and golf cart rentals.

Visit their website for more info and hours of operation.

Keylime Bistro (formerly Loose Caboose)

*Currently closed due to hurricane damage.

Visit their website or Facebook page for the latest updates.

Newlin’s Mainely Gourment

Category: Prepared foods, catering, gifts

Newlin’s blends casual elegance with creative cuisine, offering options inspired by seasonal and local ingredients. Whether it’s a perfectly prepared lobster roll or elegantly catered hors d’oeuvres, it’s always thoughtfully prepared. With its incredibly cozy atmosphere, it’s a fantastic choice.

Visit their Instagram for the latest updates.

The Pink Elephant

Category: Lunch, dinner

Known affectionately as “The Pink,” this iconic spot belonging to The Gasparilla Inn & Club is a must-visit for anyone on the island. Their signature dishes include the world-class Grilled Grouper Sandwich and their Key Lime Pie, which is as tropical and zesty as a Florida beach day. The upscale yet relaxed vibe makes you feel like you’re indulging without any hint of pretense. It’s the place to go for a dinner date or a long lunch with friends. Oh, and be sure to order a cocktail to get one of their signature pink elephants sitting atop the glass.

Visit their website for hours of operation, and be sure to check the latest dress code requirements.

The Pink Pony

Category: Ice cream, coffee, smoothies

You can’t spend time on Gasparilla Island without visiting the local ice cream spot. From cool cones that keep you refreshed in the afternoon heat to creamy creations perfect for dessert, you’ll find some local gems to satisfy your sweet tooth. The Pink Pony is always a crowd favorite, offering unique flavors that keep both kids and adults grinning.

Visit their website for the menu and hours of operation.

Scarpa’s Coastal

Scarpa’s Coastal is a standout for those craving Italian-inspired dishes with a coastal twist. The elegant yet approachable atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for both casual dinners and special occasions. Don’t miss their signature Lobster Ravioli—it’s a fan favorite for a reason.

Visit their website for the menu and hours of operation.

South Beach Bar & Grille

Category: Lunch, dinner

Another local favorite that was out of commission due to hurricane damage, South Beach Bar & Grille is back! If your vacation dream involves dining with your toes in the sand and the sun setting before you, South Beach should be on your list. This spot offers unmatched waterfront views paired with an equally stunning menu. Try the Blackened Grouper Tacos or indulge in their Lobster Bisque—it’s like the beach, but in food form. For the full experience, grab a table just before sunset for a view that’ll make your whole trip.

Visit their website for the menu and hours of operation.

The Temptation Restaurant & Bar

Category: Lunch, dinner

“The Temp,” as locals call it, is a haven for Southern-inspired dishes with a seafood twist. From Fried Green Tomatoes to Shrimp and Grits, their menu serves comfort food with sophisticated flair. The atmosphere is intimate, with a nostalgic old-Florida vibe that practically begs for a leisurely dinner where you can sip on a handcrafted cocktail. If you’re seeking somewhere to celebrate or just want a memorable meal, it’s worth every penny.

Visit their Facebook page for the latest updates.

Tortuga

Category: Breakfast, lunch

For bold, fresh flavors, head to Tortuga Mexican Street Cuisine, located inside The Pink Pony. This island gem serves up authentic Mexican dishes like Tacos al Pastor and zesty ceviche—all made from scratch. The vibrant atmosphere and unforgettable flavors bring a fun twist to your culinary tour of Boca Grande.

Visit their website for the menu and hours of operation.